How car accident settlements are estimated
A first-look estimate adds your economic damages (bills, lost pay and property damage) to a pain-and-suffering amount, found by multiplying your medical costs by a band from 1.5 to 5 based on injury level. It then reduces the total by your share of fault, or to zero if your state bars recovery at your share.
Our settlement range calculator uses the multiplier method, a common shorthand for a first look at a claim. Here is every step, so you can check the math yourself.
Step 1: what counts as economic damages?
Economic damages (E) are losses with a receipt: medical bills so far, expected future medical costs, lost pay so far, expected future lost pay, and vehicle or property damage. We add them up as entered.
E = medical + future medical + lost pay + future lost pay + property damage
Step 2: how is pain and suffering estimated?
We multiply your medical costs (bills so far plus future medical) by a band that matches the injury level. That gives a low and high pain-and-suffering estimate (P).
P = medical costs × severity multiplier
| Injury level | Example | Multiplier |
|---|---|---|
| Minor | Healed with short treatment | 1.5–2 |
| Moderate | Weeks to months of treatment or therapy | 2–3 |
| Serious | Fracture, procedure or long recovery | 3–4 |
| Severe | Surgery, lasting impairment or permanent injury | 4–5 |
These bands are conventional adjuster shorthand. They are not law and not our data, and no court or insurer is bound by them.
Why multiply medical costs only?
Some tools multiply all economic damages. We multiply medical costs only, because pain and suffering tracks the injury and its treatment, not car repairs or pay. That keeps a large repair bill from inflating the pain-and-suffering estimate.
What about the per diem method?
Another method assigns a daily amount for each day of recovery. We don’t use it, because the daily rate is a guess that changes the answer more than any input you can document.
Step 3: how does fault change the range?
The range before fault is E + P. Then your share of fault is applied:
- Barred above 50%: damages are reduced by your share, and nothing is recovered if your share is over 50%. This is the rule in New Jersey,1 New York for motor vehicle actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026,23 Florida4 and Pennsylvania.5
- Other states: you choose the rule, or leave it as “I don’t know” and no fault adjustment is made. Options are pure comparative fault (reduced, never barred), barred at 50% or more, barred above 50%, and contributory negligence (any fault bars recovery). We don’t pick the rule for you, because we haven’t checked every state’s statute.
Step 4: why does the policy limit matter?
If you enter the other driver’s liability limit and the range is above it, the calculator warns you. Amounts above the limit may need another source, such as your own underinsured motorist coverage.
Step 5: what about no-fault thresholds?
In no-fault states, PIP pays medical bills first, and pain and suffering may require an injury that meets a legal threshold. The calculator shows a note for your state but never decides whether the threshold is met. See no-fault vs. at-fault states.
What are the limits of this method?
- It uses only your numbers. We publish no average settlement figures.
- It doesn’t account for liens, legal fees, or bills your own coverage already paid.
- Real outcomes depend on evidence, credibility, venue and negotiation, which no formula captures.
What this means for your claim
Use the range to ask better questions, not as a target. Try the calculator with your numbers, then read whether to accept a first offer and what to expect in soft tissue claims.
Sources
We checked each source below on November 17, 2026. Laws change, so check the current text before you rely on it.
- N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, New Jersey Legislature — comparative negligence
- N.Y. CPLR 1411, NY Senate Open Legislation — comparative fault, including the motor vehicle rule in 1411(b)
- NY Department of Financial Services, Insurance Circular Letter No. 3 (2026) — 2026 changes to Insurance Law §§ 5102(d) and 5104 and CPLR 1411, for actions commenced on or after May 26, 2026
- Fla. Stat. § 768.81, Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine) — comparative fault and the more-than-50% bar
- 42 Pa.C.S. § 7102, Pennsylvania General Assembly — comparative negligence
General information only, not legal advice. Injury Manual is not a law firm or lawyer referral service, and no attorney–client relationship is formed. Results vary. We may be paid by partners for referrals. For advice, consult a licensed attorney in your state.
